Ocean Bay Park Homes for Rent

    Email us at rentals@fisr.com with your budget, dates and criteria, and we will get back to you with a list of homes that meet your needs!

    Ocean Bay Park lies between Seaview and Point O Woods. If Ocean Beach is the Manhattan of Fire Island and Seaview is its tony suburbs, Ocean Bay Park is its Brooklyn. Known for its relaxed and laid back environment, the community prides itself on its freedom from the restrictions, village taxes and homeowners association dues that come with the territory in neighboring communities. Formerly a haven for sharehouses and the occasional raucous party, Ocean Bay Park has been undergoing a radical transformation in recent years. Much like in gentrifying Brooklyn, families are buying up beat up bungalows and pouring capital into renovations and new home builds everywhere you look. Ocean Bay Park is also particularly attractive to buyers of investment properties because the areas low taxes keep carrying costs down. Additionally, Ocean Bay Park is subject to the Town of Brookhaven zoning code which is more permissive than the neighboring township of Islips rules. The standard lot size in Ocean Bay Park is 50 X 100.

    Direct ferry service from Bay Shore lands you in the heart of the Ocean Bay Park commercial district, which gives off a bohemian and breezy vibe. In town, experience bay front dining at Schooners and Flynns, a pizza parlor, ice cream shop, bagel store & deli, grocery store, and a bicycle rental shop. Head down Cayuga Street towards the beach and youre at the Fire Island Hotel, where you can grab a bite to eat at Hurricanes Bar & Grill or hang out by the pool. Relaxation is paramount in Ocean Bay Park, so make sure you hit the beach. Head over for the 4th of July to enjoy the Fire Department sponsored BBQ or the third week of August to experience the annual Gourmet Fair, which showcases food from local businesses and homeowners. Whether you are looking to buy, rent or day trip, Ocean Bay Park welcomes all!

    to
     
     
     
    Search Search
    •  
    Search

    33  properties match your search;

    Save Search
    Showing 11 - 20 of 33 results| view:  results per page« 1|2|3|4 »
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $9,000
      4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-14er
      Modern home in quiet location in Ocean Bay Park, close to the ocean and the Seaview border. Featuring fabulous soaring ceilings, this home feels spacious, light, and airy. Massive windows in every room. Open floor plan with sunken living room. 4 bedrooms, 2 full baths. Recently renovated kitchen! All new furnishings! Central air conditioning and heat. Two minutes to the beach! <br>
      Call Today: 631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Alyssa O'Keefe
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $10,000
      5 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-58
      Spectacular contemporary home with 5 bedrooms, 3 bath with large decks and very close to the beach!
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $11,000
      5 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# obp-10r
      5 BR home has an inverted layout that's perfect for entertaining! With large, open living space upstairs, there are great views of the bay and can hear the ocean as you are above most house tops in the area. This house is large and very spacious, providing you and your family ample room to "spread out". Bedrooms have plenty of space. Lower deck provides a great spot to have a nice morning coffee and listen to the birds. All bedrooms have air conditioning. The full house has wireless internet and Hulu with Live TV in the living room and every bedroom. Large grill provided with propane as well as house amenities (laundry & detergent, cleaning supplies, toilet paper, paper towels, hand soap, dishwasher detergent). Bikes provided with the house for your use. <br> First Floor: <br> Bedroom 1 - 2 bunk beds with full on bottom and twin on top (4 mattresses total) <br> Bedroom 2 - 1 bunk bed with full on bottom and twin on top and one twin bed <br> Bedroom 3 - 1 queen size bed <br> Bedroom 4 - 1 queen size bed <br> 2 Full Baths - one with tub <br> Laundry Room with 2 washers and dryers <br> Deck with seating and private outdoor shower with hot water <br> Second Floor (open floor plan): <br> Large Living Room. Large Kitchen and Dining Room (seats 13). Large French Doors from Dining Room to Deck <br> Master Bedroom w/ queen bed (sleeps 2) <br> Half Bath <br> Large entertaining deck with grill, with French Doors to Dining Room/Kitchen <br> Amenities: Air Conditioning in all bedrooms. Double Stacked Washer/Dryer. Blankets. Hulu with LiveTV in All Bedrooms and the Living Room. Wireless Internet. BBQ Grill and Propane Gas. Fully Stocked Kitchen. Beach Chairs & Umbrella's. Bicycles
      Call Today: 631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Alyssa O'Keefe
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $12,000
      4 Bedrooms 4 Full Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# obp-27
      Don't miss this opportunity to rent this beautiful home in Ocean Bay Park. This home has all you could need to make your summer vacation perfect! From the pool to the roof top deck to the two dens you won't run out of places to hang out in this home. The views from the roof top deck are stunning, after a long day at the beach make your way up top to watch as the sun sets over Fire Island. Plenty of room for you and your guests in this 4 bedroom, 4 full bathroom home.
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $12,500
      4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-5r
      Located right on the Bay in Ocean Bay Park, this house was completely renovated in 2023 from top to bottom, inside & out! This home provides all you need to enjoy your stay on Fire Island! Spacious deck allows for plenty of outdoor entertaining, dining and sunbathing with epic bay views. You can easily spend the whole day here with your own private beach area below complete with outdoor shower, chaises, kayaks and more! Stay cool & comfortable with ductless AC throughout. <br>
      Call Today: 631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Alyssa O'Keefe
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $12,500
      4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-33O
      Upscale, stylish home, designed for beauty and comfort, located just a few steps from the beach with fabulous ocean views from all of the rooms. Four bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, one half bath and a luxurious outdoor shower. Sleeps 10. <br> <br> Airy and bright, surrounded by glass, the vaulted sunken living room, dining area and stainless and granite kitchen all open onto a huge deck with extraordinary ocean views. Dine indoors or out. The kitchen is a chef’s delight, with loads of preparation space, quality appliances and plentiful cookware and tableware. Heat and AC, two flat screen TV’s with Direct TV, large BBQ grill, dishwasher, microwave, washer, dryer and free high speed wireless internet. Perfect for a beach vacation or work from “home”. <br> <br> All bedding, towels, beach chairs and household basics are provided. Just bring your family, friends and a smile. It doesn’t get better than this. <br> Weekly Rental Availability asking $12,500 for July weeks and $13,888 for August Weeks: <br> July 1st-July 8th <br> August 5th-August 12th <br> August 26th-September 2nd <br> September 2nd- September 9th <br> September 9th-16th <br> Available Mid May - June 21st Weekly or Long Weekends and September 16th-Mid November
      Call Today: 347-266-6594, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Samantha Raimond
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $14,000
      4 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-37SR
      This 4 bedroom,2.5 bath modern beach home has floor to ceiling windows overlooking the ocean. Views to both the bay and the ocean from every room in the home. Outdoor deck with dining area where you can watch the sunsets on the bay or the waves on the ocean. High ceilings, appointed with beautiful new high end furnishings. Hardwood floors, mahogany deck, stainless appliances, stone counter tops, outdoor shower and all the amenities of home. Impeccably kept with central air and heat, ceiling fans in every bedroom room. Private deck off the master. Steps to the beach. <br> Bedroom breakdown is as follows: <br> Queen <br> Queen <br> 2 full beds <br> Pull out queen sleeper sofa
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $15,000
      2 Bedrooms 1 Full Bath
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-1R
      Come stay in this charming two bedroom Ocean Bay Park!
      Call Today: 631-583-8898, 516-521-6842, or  Email: Joan Woletsky
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $15,000
      5 Bedrooms 2 Full Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# obp-38r
      Perfect Fire Island Oceanfront Location. Have your coffee with the sunrise and your wine with the sunset on the cozy outdoor couches or watch the waves through walls of glass from inside this contemporary 5 bedroom 2 bath house. Enjoy this magnificent beachfront location from the huge wraparound deck of your own private modern retreat. Right on the ocean. 2 full clean modern bathrooms plus brand new outdoor shower! one 50 inch and another 32 inch smart TV, blu-ray DVD player, wireless internet, built in surround sound, built in bluetooth deck speakers you. Open living room/kitchen layout with 2 sets of sliding glass doors to large deck overlooking the ocean! Everything you need for a perfect vacation including central air, a BBQ, 2 outdoor dining tables, outdoor sofa sets, beach chairs, toys, bikes, wagon, umbrella, kitchenware, linens and towels. House is recently renovated and meticulously maintained, including kitchen with granite counter tops, bamboo floors and central air. Outdoor shower is a Fire Island necessity so you can listen to the waves while you shower. <br> Bedroom 1: queen <br> Bedroom 2: queen <br> Bedroom 3: 2 singles <br> Bedroom 4: single and bunk bed <br> Bedroom 5: single and bunk bed <br> Availability: <br> Weekly Rent June 21st-June 28th, August 16th-August 23rd, August 23rd-August 30th. <BR> Weekly and Long Weekend Availability in May/June and September/October for lower rate.
      Call Today: 347-266-6594, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Samantha Raimond
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    • Ocean Bay Park, NY
      $16,500
      5 Bedrooms 3 Full Baths 2 Half Baths
      Single Family For Rent ID# OBP-36r
      This 2 story home is one of a kind in Ocean Bay Park! Built in 2016, it offers upper and lower decks along with a roof deck and a 360 degree view of the island, ocean and bay. It is a luxurious 5 bedroom 3 full bathrooms with 2 half baths just off the dunes with incredible ocean views. A private outdoor shower is located on the main level deck. Vacation in this state of the art home that can sleep 12 with family and friends. <br>
      Call Today: 631-988-0819, 631-583-8898, or  Email: Alyssa O'Keefe
      Call Today: or  Email: Fire Island Rentals
    Showing 11 - 20 of 33 results| view:  results per page« 1|2|3|4 »
    FireIsland

    Questions? Just Ask!

      Submit