About Us

Carin Roth: Owner/Broker

In partnership with her father, Ernest Roth, Carin founded Fire Island Real Estate in 1977 as a division of Roth Builders, which had been building and renovating homes on Fire Island since the early 1950s.  A licensed agent since 1974 and a licensed broker since 1977, Carin went directly into real estate after attending Brandeis University. Carin has been actively engaged in the Fire Island market ever since, and has been through several economic cycles, thriving through boom as well as bust.  Her longevity is a testament to her commitment to serving first and foremost the best interests of her clients, as well as the deal-making ability for which she is known.  Carin owns properties in Ocean Beach, Seaview, and Ocean Bay Park, and is therefore acutely aware of the dynamics of real estate ownership and investment on the island.

Abigail Medvin Mago: Licensed Associate Broker

Abigail MedvinAbigail Medvin Mago is a Licensed Associate Broker and has been a New York State real estate licensee for more than 10 years. Prior to joining Fire Island Real Estate, Abi was a Sales Associate at Brown Harris Stevens in Manhattan where she serviced over $75 million worth of transactions. Known for her organization and attention to detail, Abi is committed to providing the highest level of client service and can be reached on her smartphone at any time. Having spent her every summer on Fire Island, Abi is a local expert. Actively involved in the community, she is the former owner of Fire Island Ice Cream Company (presently Beaches and Cream).  She owns and manages investment properties in Corneille Estates, Ocean Beach, Seaview, and Ocean Bay Park.  Abi holds a Bachelor's degree in Psychological and Brain Sciences from Dartmouth College as well as a Master's in Real Estate Development from New York University's Schack Institute of Real Estate.  She splits her time between her family home in Ocean Beach and her mainland residence in Syosset.